Kant i legitimnost pobune protiv suverena
Kant and the legitimacy of rebellion against the sovereign
Апстракт
U ovom radu razmatraću Kantov odgovor na pitanje opravdanosti pobune građana protiv vladara jedne države. Prvi deo rada uvodi teoriju društvenog ugovora i razmatraju se tri poznata odgovora na ovo pitanje - Hobsovo, Lokovo i Rusoovo. U drugom delu predstavljam Kantovu poziciju oslanjajući se na ona dela u kojima neposredno razmatra odnos vlasti i građana. Obično se smatra da Kant veruje u neopravdanost i, štaviše, protivrečnost mogućnosti izvođenja revolucije unutar jednog društva odnosno nasilnog zbacivanja vladara. Treći deo rada posvećen je alternativnoj poziciji koja bi se mogla pripisati Kantu na osnovu tekstualnog svedočanstva prisutnog u delu koje se prima facie može činiti irelevantnim u kontekstu političke filozofije - Kritici moći suđenja.
The main topic of this paper is Kant's position with respect to whether rebellion of citizens against their sovereign is justified. The first part of the paper introduces the social contract theory and considers three well-known answers to this question - Hobbes's Locke's and Rousseau's. In the second part I deal with Kant's views relying on those of his works where the relation between government and citizens is the chief subject. It is usually thought that Kant believes that rebellion, or revolution against sovereign is unjustified, or even contradictory. In the third part of the paper I try to outline an alternative interpretation that ascribes him the positive attitude towards revolution in certain contexts, and to which I arrive by using mainly the textual evidence present in the Critique of Judgment.
Кључне речи:
suverenitet / prirodno stanje / pobuna / Kant / građanin / država / state / sovereignty / rebellion / natural state / Kant / citizenИзвор:
Theoria, 2013, 56, 4, 63-77Издавач:
- Srpsko filozofsko društvo, Beograd
Финансирање / пројекти:
- Логичко-епистемолошки основи метафизике (RS-MESTD-Basic Research (BR or ON)-179067)
Институција/група
Filozofija / PhilosophyTY - JOUR AU - Šoć, Andrija PY - 2013 UR - http://reff.f.bg.ac.rs/handle/123456789/1676 AB - U ovom radu razmatraću Kantov odgovor na pitanje opravdanosti pobune građana protiv vladara jedne države. Prvi deo rada uvodi teoriju društvenog ugovora i razmatraju se tri poznata odgovora na ovo pitanje - Hobsovo, Lokovo i Rusoovo. U drugom delu predstavljam Kantovu poziciju oslanjajući se na ona dela u kojima neposredno razmatra odnos vlasti i građana. Obično se smatra da Kant veruje u neopravdanost i, štaviše, protivrečnost mogućnosti izvođenja revolucije unutar jednog društva odnosno nasilnog zbacivanja vladara. Treći deo rada posvećen je alternativnoj poziciji koja bi se mogla pripisati Kantu na osnovu tekstualnog svedočanstva prisutnog u delu koje se prima facie može činiti irelevantnim u kontekstu političke filozofije - Kritici moći suđenja. AB - The main topic of this paper is Kant's position with respect to whether rebellion of citizens against their sovereign is justified. The first part of the paper introduces the social contract theory and considers three well-known answers to this question - Hobbes's Locke's and Rousseau's. In the second part I deal with Kant's views relying on those of his works where the relation between government and citizens is the chief subject. It is usually thought that Kant believes that rebellion, or revolution against sovereign is unjustified, or even contradictory. In the third part of the paper I try to outline an alternative interpretation that ascribes him the positive attitude towards revolution in certain contexts, and to which I arrive by using mainly the textual evidence present in the Critique of Judgment. PB - Srpsko filozofsko društvo, Beograd T2 - Theoria T1 - Kant i legitimnost pobune protiv suverena T1 - Kant and the legitimacy of rebellion against the sovereign EP - 77 IS - 4 SP - 63 VL - 56 UR - https://hdl.handle.net/21.15107/rcub_reff_1676 ER -
@article{ author = "Šoć, Andrija", year = "2013", abstract = "U ovom radu razmatraću Kantov odgovor na pitanje opravdanosti pobune građana protiv vladara jedne države. Prvi deo rada uvodi teoriju društvenog ugovora i razmatraju se tri poznata odgovora na ovo pitanje - Hobsovo, Lokovo i Rusoovo. U drugom delu predstavljam Kantovu poziciju oslanjajući se na ona dela u kojima neposredno razmatra odnos vlasti i građana. Obično se smatra da Kant veruje u neopravdanost i, štaviše, protivrečnost mogućnosti izvođenja revolucije unutar jednog društva odnosno nasilnog zbacivanja vladara. Treći deo rada posvećen je alternativnoj poziciji koja bi se mogla pripisati Kantu na osnovu tekstualnog svedočanstva prisutnog u delu koje se prima facie može činiti irelevantnim u kontekstu političke filozofije - Kritici moći suđenja., The main topic of this paper is Kant's position with respect to whether rebellion of citizens against their sovereign is justified. The first part of the paper introduces the social contract theory and considers three well-known answers to this question - Hobbes's Locke's and Rousseau's. In the second part I deal with Kant's views relying on those of his works where the relation between government and citizens is the chief subject. It is usually thought that Kant believes that rebellion, or revolution against sovereign is unjustified, or even contradictory. In the third part of the paper I try to outline an alternative interpretation that ascribes him the positive attitude towards revolution in certain contexts, and to which I arrive by using mainly the textual evidence present in the Critique of Judgment.", publisher = "Srpsko filozofsko društvo, Beograd", journal = "Theoria", title = "Kant i legitimnost pobune protiv suverena, Kant and the legitimacy of rebellion against the sovereign", pages = "77-63", number = "4", volume = "56", url = "https://hdl.handle.net/21.15107/rcub_reff_1676" }
Šoć, A.. (2013). Kant i legitimnost pobune protiv suverena. in Theoria Srpsko filozofsko društvo, Beograd., 56(4), 63-77. https://hdl.handle.net/21.15107/rcub_reff_1676
Šoć A. Kant i legitimnost pobune protiv suverena. in Theoria. 2013;56(4):63-77. https://hdl.handle.net/21.15107/rcub_reff_1676 .
Šoć, Andrija, "Kant i legitimnost pobune protiv suverena" in Theoria, 56, no. 4 (2013):63-77, https://hdl.handle.net/21.15107/rcub_reff_1676 .