Problem nesvesnih perceptivnih stanja
The problem of unconscious perceptual states
Apstrakt
Prema tradicionalnom gledištu, veza između naših perceptivnih stanja i svesnosti je pojmovno nužna. U ovom radu ću pokušati da predstavim argumentaciju koja ovu tezu dovodi u pitanje. Rad je podeljen na dva glavna dela. U prvom delu se detaljno analizira pojam nesvesne percepcije, kao i nekoliko fenomena u savremenoj kliničkoj literaturi koji pružaju empirijsku podršku tvrđenju da slučajevi nesvesnih perceptivnih stanja zaista postoje. Diskusija u prvom delu rada će mi omogućiti da razmotrim neke od osnovnih teza dve popularne teorije u savremenoj filozofiji percepcije-reprezentacionalizma i relacionalizma. Glavna teza koju ću nastojati da odbranim u drugom delu rada je da u kontekstu filozofskog problema nesvesnih perceptivnih stanja, reprezentacionalističkoj poziciji treba dati značajnu prednost u odnosu na relacionalizam.
According to the traditional view-most commonly associated with G. E. Moo-re-the relation between our perception and consciousness is conceptually necessary. This paper argues against this view. The first part of the paper discusses the concept of unconscious perception, as well as several interesting phenomena in the recent clinical literature that give us persuasive evidence against the thesis that, as a matter of conceptual or a priori necessity, perception cannot occur without consciousness. The second part of the paper provides a thorough critical analysis of the two popular positions in the philosophy of perception-namely, representationalism and relationalism-in order to determine whether and how successfully they can account for the claim about the existence of unconscious perceptual states. I conclude that, at least in the context of the philosophical debate about unconscious perception, there are strong reasons to favor the representationalist account.
Ključne reči:
slepi vid. / reprezentacionalizam / relacionalizam / nesvesna perceptivna stanja / unconscious perceptual states / representationalism / relationalism / blindsightIzvor:
Theoria, 2019, 62, 3, 95-109Izdavač:
- Srpsko filozofsko društvo, Beograd
Institucija/grupa
Filozofija / PhilosophyTY - JOUR AU - Sokić, Mirjana PY - 2019 UR - http://reff.f.bg.ac.rs/handle/123456789/2813 AB - Prema tradicionalnom gledištu, veza između naših perceptivnih stanja i svesnosti je pojmovno nužna. U ovom radu ću pokušati da predstavim argumentaciju koja ovu tezu dovodi u pitanje. Rad je podeljen na dva glavna dela. U prvom delu se detaljno analizira pojam nesvesne percepcije, kao i nekoliko fenomena u savremenoj kliničkoj literaturi koji pružaju empirijsku podršku tvrđenju da slučajevi nesvesnih perceptivnih stanja zaista postoje. Diskusija u prvom delu rada će mi omogućiti da razmotrim neke od osnovnih teza dve popularne teorije u savremenoj filozofiji percepcije-reprezentacionalizma i relacionalizma. Glavna teza koju ću nastojati da odbranim u drugom delu rada je da u kontekstu filozofskog problema nesvesnih perceptivnih stanja, reprezentacionalističkoj poziciji treba dati značajnu prednost u odnosu na relacionalizam. AB - According to the traditional view-most commonly associated with G. E. Moo-re-the relation between our perception and consciousness is conceptually necessary. This paper argues against this view. The first part of the paper discusses the concept of unconscious perception, as well as several interesting phenomena in the recent clinical literature that give us persuasive evidence against the thesis that, as a matter of conceptual or a priori necessity, perception cannot occur without consciousness. The second part of the paper provides a thorough critical analysis of the two popular positions in the philosophy of perception-namely, representationalism and relationalism-in order to determine whether and how successfully they can account for the claim about the existence of unconscious perceptual states. I conclude that, at least in the context of the philosophical debate about unconscious perception, there are strong reasons to favor the representationalist account. PB - Srpsko filozofsko društvo, Beograd T2 - Theoria T1 - Problem nesvesnih perceptivnih stanja T1 - The problem of unconscious perceptual states EP - 109 IS - 3 SP - 95 VL - 62 DO - 10.2298/THEO1903095S ER -
@article{ author = "Sokić, Mirjana", year = "2019", abstract = "Prema tradicionalnom gledištu, veza između naših perceptivnih stanja i svesnosti je pojmovno nužna. U ovom radu ću pokušati da predstavim argumentaciju koja ovu tezu dovodi u pitanje. Rad je podeljen na dva glavna dela. U prvom delu se detaljno analizira pojam nesvesne percepcije, kao i nekoliko fenomena u savremenoj kliničkoj literaturi koji pružaju empirijsku podršku tvrđenju da slučajevi nesvesnih perceptivnih stanja zaista postoje. Diskusija u prvom delu rada će mi omogućiti da razmotrim neke od osnovnih teza dve popularne teorije u savremenoj filozofiji percepcije-reprezentacionalizma i relacionalizma. Glavna teza koju ću nastojati da odbranim u drugom delu rada je da u kontekstu filozofskog problema nesvesnih perceptivnih stanja, reprezentacionalističkoj poziciji treba dati značajnu prednost u odnosu na relacionalizam., According to the traditional view-most commonly associated with G. E. Moo-re-the relation between our perception and consciousness is conceptually necessary. This paper argues against this view. The first part of the paper discusses the concept of unconscious perception, as well as several interesting phenomena in the recent clinical literature that give us persuasive evidence against the thesis that, as a matter of conceptual or a priori necessity, perception cannot occur without consciousness. The second part of the paper provides a thorough critical analysis of the two popular positions in the philosophy of perception-namely, representationalism and relationalism-in order to determine whether and how successfully they can account for the claim about the existence of unconscious perceptual states. I conclude that, at least in the context of the philosophical debate about unconscious perception, there are strong reasons to favor the representationalist account.", publisher = "Srpsko filozofsko društvo, Beograd", journal = "Theoria", title = "Problem nesvesnih perceptivnih stanja, The problem of unconscious perceptual states", pages = "109-95", number = "3", volume = "62", doi = "10.2298/THEO1903095S" }
Sokić, M.. (2019). Problem nesvesnih perceptivnih stanja. in Theoria Srpsko filozofsko društvo, Beograd., 62(3), 95-109. https://doi.org/10.2298/THEO1903095S
Sokić M. Problem nesvesnih perceptivnih stanja. in Theoria. 2019;62(3):95-109. doi:10.2298/THEO1903095S .
Sokić, Mirjana, "Problem nesvesnih perceptivnih stanja" in Theoria, 62, no. 3 (2019):95-109, https://doi.org/10.2298/THEO1903095S . .