Stressful times for women-Reply to Edinborough et al. (2021)
Нема приказа
Аутори
Penezić, KristinaPorčić, Marko
Urban, Petra Kathrin
Wittwer-Backofen, Ursula
Stefanović, Sofija
Чланак у часопису (Објављена верзија)
Метаподаци
Приказ свих података о документуАпстракт
This work is a reply to the comment by Edinborough et al. (2021) on our recently published paper (Penezic ' et al., 2020). In our original paper we presented the results based on the tooth cementum annulation analysis that show that the Neolithic females had higher levels of physiological stress than the Mesolithic females in the Central Balkans. We proposed the hypothesis that this was caused by differences in fertility. In their comment on our paper, Edinborough et al. (2021) question: 1) the accuracy and precision of the TCA analysis as the age estimation method 2) that pregnancies leave traces in the tooth cementum 3) our interpretation of the results. In this reply we argue: 1) that the TCA is a reliable method for age estimation 2) that the reflection of pregnancies in the tooth cementum was established by independent and previously published research and 3) we clarify that our interpretation - that the increased fertility in the Neolithic period may be the cause of the observed ...patterns - is a hypothesis that needs to be further tested rather than the final conclusion of our original paper.
Кључне речи:
Tooth cementum annulation / Pregnancy / Physiological stress / Neolithic / Mesolithic / FertilityИзвор:
Journal of Archaeological Science, 2021, 134Издавач:
- Academic Press Ltd- Elsevier Science Ltd, London
Финансирање / пројекти:
- Births, mothers and babies: prehistoric fertility in the Balkans between 10000-5000 BC (EU-H2020-640557)
DOI: 10.1016/j.jas.2021.105464
ISSN: 0305-4403
WoS: 000697177900004
Scopus: 2-s2.0-85114441899
Институција/група
Arheologija / ArchaeologyTY - JOUR AU - Penezić, Kristina AU - Porčić, Marko AU - Urban, Petra Kathrin AU - Wittwer-Backofen, Ursula AU - Stefanović, Sofija PY - 2021 UR - http://reff.f.bg.ac.rs/handle/123456789/3315 AB - This work is a reply to the comment by Edinborough et al. (2021) on our recently published paper (Penezic ' et al., 2020). In our original paper we presented the results based on the tooth cementum annulation analysis that show that the Neolithic females had higher levels of physiological stress than the Mesolithic females in the Central Balkans. We proposed the hypothesis that this was caused by differences in fertility. In their comment on our paper, Edinborough et al. (2021) question: 1) the accuracy and precision of the TCA analysis as the age estimation method 2) that pregnancies leave traces in the tooth cementum 3) our interpretation of the results. In this reply we argue: 1) that the TCA is a reliable method for age estimation 2) that the reflection of pregnancies in the tooth cementum was established by independent and previously published research and 3) we clarify that our interpretation - that the increased fertility in the Neolithic period may be the cause of the observed patterns - is a hypothesis that needs to be further tested rather than the final conclusion of our original paper. PB - Academic Press Ltd- Elsevier Science Ltd, London T2 - Journal of Archaeological Science T1 - Stressful times for women-Reply to Edinborough et al. (2021) VL - 134 DO - 10.1016/j.jas.2021.105464 ER -
@article{ author = "Penezić, Kristina and Porčić, Marko and Urban, Petra Kathrin and Wittwer-Backofen, Ursula and Stefanović, Sofija", year = "2021", abstract = "This work is a reply to the comment by Edinborough et al. (2021) on our recently published paper (Penezic ' et al., 2020). In our original paper we presented the results based on the tooth cementum annulation analysis that show that the Neolithic females had higher levels of physiological stress than the Mesolithic females in the Central Balkans. We proposed the hypothesis that this was caused by differences in fertility. In their comment on our paper, Edinborough et al. (2021) question: 1) the accuracy and precision of the TCA analysis as the age estimation method 2) that pregnancies leave traces in the tooth cementum 3) our interpretation of the results. In this reply we argue: 1) that the TCA is a reliable method for age estimation 2) that the reflection of pregnancies in the tooth cementum was established by independent and previously published research and 3) we clarify that our interpretation - that the increased fertility in the Neolithic period may be the cause of the observed patterns - is a hypothesis that needs to be further tested rather than the final conclusion of our original paper.", publisher = "Academic Press Ltd- Elsevier Science Ltd, London", journal = "Journal of Archaeological Science", title = "Stressful times for women-Reply to Edinborough et al. (2021)", volume = "134", doi = "10.1016/j.jas.2021.105464" }
Penezić, K., Porčić, M., Urban, P. K., Wittwer-Backofen, U.,& Stefanović, S.. (2021). Stressful times for women-Reply to Edinborough et al. (2021). in Journal of Archaeological Science Academic Press Ltd- Elsevier Science Ltd, London., 134. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jas.2021.105464
Penezić K, Porčić M, Urban PK, Wittwer-Backofen U, Stefanović S. Stressful times for women-Reply to Edinborough et al. (2021). in Journal of Archaeological Science. 2021;134. doi:10.1016/j.jas.2021.105464 .
Penezić, Kristina, Porčić, Marko, Urban, Petra Kathrin, Wittwer-Backofen, Ursula, Stefanović, Sofija, "Stressful times for women-Reply to Edinborough et al. (2021)" in Journal of Archaeological Science, 134 (2021), https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jas.2021.105464 . .