Mitigation and Linguistic Epistemic Tolerance as Requirements for Linguistically Inclusive Science: A Dialogue with Vitaly Pronskikh
Апстракт
In our paper “How to Fight Linguistic Injustice in Science: Equity Measures and Mitigating Agents” (2023), we discuss the challenges that non-native English speakers face in communicating their scientific findings. We explored several obstacles they/we encounter, with the most severe leading to epistemic injustice. In his critical reply “Do Scientists Need Mitigating Agents and Who is Responsible for Providing Them? Musings on Vučković and Sikimić’s ‘How to Fight Linguistic Injustice in Science’“, Vitaly Pronskikh raises several riveting questions that need further exploration, which inspired us to approach this topic once again and to further explore the consequences of the solutions we propose.
U našem radu "How to Fight Linguistic Injustice in Science: Equity Measures and Mitigating Agents", razgovaramo o izazovima sa kojima se, pri komunikaciji naučnih otkrića, susreću istraživači kojima engleski nije maternji jezik. Istraživale smo nekoliko prepreka sa kojima se oni/mi suočavamo, među kojima su najozbiljnije one koje dovode do epistemičke nepravde. U svom kritičkom odgovoru "Do Scientists Need Mitigating Agents and Who is Responsible for Providing Them? Musings on Vučković and Sikimić's 'How to Fight Linguistic Injustice in Science: Equity Measures and Mitigating Agents'", Vitali Pronski postavlja nekolicinu uzbudljivih pitanja koja iziskuju dalje ispitivanje. To nas je inspirisalo da se još jednom vratimo ovoj temi i da dodatno preispitamo dalje posledice rešenja koja predlažemo
Кључне речи:
epistemic tolerance / Linguistic Injustice / Mitigating Agents / scientific research / epistemička tolerancija / lingvistička nepravda / posrednici / naučna istraživanjaИзвор:
Social Epistemology Review and Reply Collective, 2023, 12, 5, 23-29Издавач:
- SERRC
Напомена:
- Naučna diskusija i polemika
Институција/група
Filozofija / PhilosophyTY - JOUR AU - Vučković, Aleksandra AU - Sikimić, Vlasta PY - 2023 UR - http://reff.f.bg.ac.rs/handle/123456789/4910 AB - In our paper “How to Fight Linguistic Injustice in Science: Equity Measures and Mitigating Agents” (2023), we discuss the challenges that non-native English speakers face in communicating their scientific findings. We explored several obstacles they/we encounter, with the most severe leading to epistemic injustice. In his critical reply “Do Scientists Need Mitigating Agents and Who is Responsible for Providing Them? Musings on Vučković and Sikimić’s ‘How to Fight Linguistic Injustice in Science’“, Vitaly Pronskikh raises several riveting questions that need further exploration, which inspired us to approach this topic once again and to further explore the consequences of the solutions we propose. AB - U našem radu "How to Fight Linguistic Injustice in Science: Equity Measures and Mitigating Agents", razgovaramo o izazovima sa kojima se, pri komunikaciji naučnih otkrića, susreću istraživači kojima engleski nije maternji jezik. Istraživale smo nekoliko prepreka sa kojima se oni/mi suočavamo, među kojima su najozbiljnije one koje dovode do epistemičke nepravde. U svom kritičkom odgovoru "Do Scientists Need Mitigating Agents and Who is Responsible for Providing Them? Musings on Vučković and Sikimić's 'How to Fight Linguistic Injustice in Science: Equity Measures and Mitigating Agents'", Vitali Pronski postavlja nekolicinu uzbudljivih pitanja koja iziskuju dalje ispitivanje. To nas je inspirisalo da se još jednom vratimo ovoj temi i da dodatno preispitamo dalje posledice rešenja koja predlažemo PB - SERRC T2 - Social Epistemology Review and Reply Collective T1 - Mitigation and Linguistic Epistemic Tolerance as Requirements for Linguistically Inclusive Science: A Dialogue with Vitaly Pronskikh EP - 29 IS - 5 SP - 23 VL - 12 UR - https://hdl.handle.net/21.15107/rcub_reff_4910 ER -
@article{ author = "Vučković, Aleksandra and Sikimić, Vlasta", year = "2023", abstract = "In our paper “How to Fight Linguistic Injustice in Science: Equity Measures and Mitigating Agents” (2023), we discuss the challenges that non-native English speakers face in communicating their scientific findings. We explored several obstacles they/we encounter, with the most severe leading to epistemic injustice. In his critical reply “Do Scientists Need Mitigating Agents and Who is Responsible for Providing Them? Musings on Vučković and Sikimić’s ‘How to Fight Linguistic Injustice in Science’“, Vitaly Pronskikh raises several riveting questions that need further exploration, which inspired us to approach this topic once again and to further explore the consequences of the solutions we propose., U našem radu "How to Fight Linguistic Injustice in Science: Equity Measures and Mitigating Agents", razgovaramo o izazovima sa kojima se, pri komunikaciji naučnih otkrića, susreću istraživači kojima engleski nije maternji jezik. Istraživale smo nekoliko prepreka sa kojima se oni/mi suočavamo, među kojima su najozbiljnije one koje dovode do epistemičke nepravde. U svom kritičkom odgovoru "Do Scientists Need Mitigating Agents and Who is Responsible for Providing Them? Musings on Vučković and Sikimić's 'How to Fight Linguistic Injustice in Science: Equity Measures and Mitigating Agents'", Vitali Pronski postavlja nekolicinu uzbudljivih pitanja koja iziskuju dalje ispitivanje. To nas je inspirisalo da se još jednom vratimo ovoj temi i da dodatno preispitamo dalje posledice rešenja koja predlažemo", publisher = "SERRC", journal = "Social Epistemology Review and Reply Collective", title = "Mitigation and Linguistic Epistemic Tolerance as Requirements for Linguistically Inclusive Science: A Dialogue with Vitaly Pronskikh", pages = "29-23", number = "5", volume = "12", url = "https://hdl.handle.net/21.15107/rcub_reff_4910" }
Vučković, A.,& Sikimić, V.. (2023). Mitigation and Linguistic Epistemic Tolerance as Requirements for Linguistically Inclusive Science: A Dialogue with Vitaly Pronskikh. in Social Epistemology Review and Reply Collective SERRC., 12(5), 23-29. https://hdl.handle.net/21.15107/rcub_reff_4910
Vučković A, Sikimić V. Mitigation and Linguistic Epistemic Tolerance as Requirements for Linguistically Inclusive Science: A Dialogue with Vitaly Pronskikh. in Social Epistemology Review and Reply Collective. 2023;12(5):23-29. https://hdl.handle.net/21.15107/rcub_reff_4910 .
Vučković, Aleksandra, Sikimić, Vlasta, "Mitigation and Linguistic Epistemic Tolerance as Requirements for Linguistically Inclusive Science: A Dialogue with Vitaly Pronskikh" in Social Epistemology Review and Reply Collective, 12, no. 5 (2023):23-29, https://hdl.handle.net/21.15107/rcub_reff_4910 .