History of Emotional Suffering: from emotions to needs in the history of emotions
Authorized Users Only
2022
Article (Published version)
,
Wesleyan University
Metadata
Show full item recordAbstract
Questions about the nature of emotions and the role of emotional expressions have been
addressed frequently in the study of the history of emotions. However, the extent to which
emotional suffering is present in the cultures and societies of the past is seldom queried.
Our first goal is to identify criteria that historians of emotions can use to evaluate the
emotional suffering of the people they study. We locate these criteria not in the theory of
emotions, whether Norbert Elias’s psychoanalytic theory or William M. Reddy’s theory of
emotives, but in the theory of basic, universal human needs proposed by Richard M. Ryan
and Edward L. Deci. Although we agree with most contemporary historians of emotions
that emotions themselves can be understood only within the context of a particular culture, we propose that additional inquiry into basic needs and their satisfaction could help
historians of emotions cast more light on the inner lives of the members of the societies
they inve...stigate. Our second goal is to apply these insights to the case of acedia, a peculiar psychological state experienced by the Desert Fathers. We examine what acedia was
for the Desert Fathers by analyzing Evagrius’s writings. Our goal here is to capture what
historians of emotions regularly do; that is, we aim to reconstruct how monks of the fourth
century felt, expressed, and thought about emotions from within their own monastic culture. In addition, we analyze acedia from the perspective of the theory of needs. In this
way, we hope to show how the theory of needs can help historians in their endeavors to
understand the past.
Keywords:
emotional suffering / history of emotions / universal psychological needs / well-being / acediaSource:
History and Theory, 2022, 61, 96-123Publisher:
- Middletown, Connecticut : Wesleyan University
Funding / projects:
- Dynamic Systems in Nature and Society: Philosophical and Empirical Aspects (RS-MESTD-Basic Research (BR or ON)-179041)
Institution/Community
Klasične nauke / Classical StudiesTY - JOUR AU - Akkad, Il AU - Radenović, Ljiljana PY - 2022 UR - http://reff.f.bg.ac.rs/handle/123456789/5654 AB - Questions about the nature of emotions and the role of emotional expressions have been addressed frequently in the study of the history of emotions. However, the extent to which emotional suffering is present in the cultures and societies of the past is seldom queried. Our first goal is to identify criteria that historians of emotions can use to evaluate the emotional suffering of the people they study. We locate these criteria not in the theory of emotions, whether Norbert Elias’s psychoanalytic theory or William M. Reddy’s theory of emotives, but in the theory of basic, universal human needs proposed by Richard M. Ryan and Edward L. Deci. Although we agree with most contemporary historians of emotions that emotions themselves can be understood only within the context of a particular culture, we propose that additional inquiry into basic needs and their satisfaction could help historians of emotions cast more light on the inner lives of the members of the societies they investigate. Our second goal is to apply these insights to the case of acedia, a peculiar psychological state experienced by the Desert Fathers. We examine what acedia was for the Desert Fathers by analyzing Evagrius’s writings. Our goal here is to capture what historians of emotions regularly do; that is, we aim to reconstruct how monks of the fourth century felt, expressed, and thought about emotions from within their own monastic culture. In addition, we analyze acedia from the perspective of the theory of needs. In this way, we hope to show how the theory of needs can help historians in their endeavors to understand the past. PB - Middletown, Connecticut : Wesleyan University T2 - History and Theory T1 - History of Emotional Suffering: from emotions to needs in the history of emotions EP - 123 IS - 61 SP - 96 DO - 10.1111/hith.12245 ER -
@article{ author = "Akkad, Il and Radenović, Ljiljana", year = "2022", abstract = "Questions about the nature of emotions and the role of emotional expressions have been addressed frequently in the study of the history of emotions. However, the extent to which emotional suffering is present in the cultures and societies of the past is seldom queried. Our first goal is to identify criteria that historians of emotions can use to evaluate the emotional suffering of the people they study. We locate these criteria not in the theory of emotions, whether Norbert Elias’s psychoanalytic theory or William M. Reddy’s theory of emotives, but in the theory of basic, universal human needs proposed by Richard M. Ryan and Edward L. Deci. Although we agree with most contemporary historians of emotions that emotions themselves can be understood only within the context of a particular culture, we propose that additional inquiry into basic needs and their satisfaction could help historians of emotions cast more light on the inner lives of the members of the societies they investigate. Our second goal is to apply these insights to the case of acedia, a peculiar psychological state experienced by the Desert Fathers. We examine what acedia was for the Desert Fathers by analyzing Evagrius’s writings. Our goal here is to capture what historians of emotions regularly do; that is, we aim to reconstruct how monks of the fourth century felt, expressed, and thought about emotions from within their own monastic culture. In addition, we analyze acedia from the perspective of the theory of needs. In this way, we hope to show how the theory of needs can help historians in their endeavors to understand the past.", publisher = "Middletown, Connecticut : Wesleyan University", journal = "History and Theory", title = "History of Emotional Suffering: from emotions to needs in the history of emotions", pages = "123-96", number = "61", doi = "10.1111/hith.12245" }
Akkad, I.,& Radenović, L.. (2022). History of Emotional Suffering: from emotions to needs in the history of emotions. in History and Theory Middletown, Connecticut : Wesleyan University.(61), 96-123. https://doi.org/10.1111/hith.12245
Akkad I, Radenović L. History of Emotional Suffering: from emotions to needs in the history of emotions. in History and Theory. 2022;(61):96-123. doi:10.1111/hith.12245 .
Akkad, Il, Radenović, Ljiljana, "History of Emotional Suffering: from emotions to needs in the history of emotions" in History and Theory, no. 61 (2022):96-123, https://doi.org/10.1111/hith.12245 . .