Asimbolički bol
Pain Asymbolia
Article (Published version)
Metadata
Show full item recordAbstract
Glavni predmet ovog rada je redak disocijativni fenomen u ljudskom iskustvu
bola, poznat kao asimbolija za bol (pain asymbolia). Prva stvar koja će se razmotriti u
ovom radu je priroda asimboličkog bola, kao i specifičnosti po kojima se ovaj bol razlikuje
od ostalih disocijativnih fenomena u ljudskom iskustvu bola. Naročita pažnja će biti
posvećena tvrdnji profesora Graheka da klasični primeri ravnodušnosti prema bolu nisu
slučajevi krajnje ili radikalne ravnodušnosti prema bolu, već da to mesto pripada upravo
asimboličkom bolu. Na kraju, videćemo koje pretnje asimbolički bol postavlja pred neke
istaknute argumente u filozofiji duha. Pokazaće se da mnogi modeli bola koji su bili
predloženi, na osnovu detaljne analize asimboličkog bola, prestaju da budu uverljivo
objašnjenje bola. Tu se, pre svega, misli na funkcionalističku analizu i tzv. perceptivni
model bola, ali se isti zaključak nameće i za subjektivističke tvrdnje, prema kojima je oset
bola suštinska komponenta našeg c...elovitog iskustva bola.
The main object of this paper is a rare syndrom in human pain experience, known as
the pain asymbolia. The first thing that will be considered in this paper is the nature of pain
asymbolia. I will try to examine and prove professor Grahek's claim that pain asymbolia
differs from other dissociation syndromes in human pain experience. Also, the special
attention will be given to Grahek's claim that typical cases of indifference to pain are not the
cases of radical or total indifference to pain. Finally, it will be shown how pain asymbolia
can be used against some famous arguments in the philosophy of mind. Namely, it can be
used to undermine both the subjectivist and the objectivist conceptions of pain. More
specifically, it can be used to disprove the functionalist interpretation of pain and the
perceptual or representational model of pain. Also, pain asymbolia can be used against the subjectivist view, according to which the sensation of pain is to be considered as the
essent...ial component of pain.
Keywords:
asimbolički bol / disocijativni fenomeni / funkcionalistička analiza / ravnodušnost prema bolu / perceptivni model bola / pain asymbolia / dissociation syndromes of human pain experience / the functionalist interpretation of pain / the perceptual or representational model of pain / subjectivist interpretation of painSource:
Theoria, 2012, 55, 2, 63-84Publisher:
- Srpsko filozofsko društvo
Institution/Community
Filozofija / PhilosophyTY - JOUR AU - Milevski, Voin PY - 2012 UR - http://reff.f.bg.ac.rs/handle/123456789/5322 AB - Glavni predmet ovog rada je redak disocijativni fenomen u ljudskom iskustvu bola, poznat kao asimbolija za bol (pain asymbolia). Prva stvar koja će se razmotriti u ovom radu je priroda asimboličkog bola, kao i specifičnosti po kojima se ovaj bol razlikuje od ostalih disocijativnih fenomena u ljudskom iskustvu bola. Naročita pažnja će biti posvećena tvrdnji profesora Graheka da klasični primeri ravnodušnosti prema bolu nisu slučajevi krajnje ili radikalne ravnodušnosti prema bolu, već da to mesto pripada upravo asimboličkom bolu. Na kraju, videćemo koje pretnje asimbolički bol postavlja pred neke istaknute argumente u filozofiji duha. Pokazaće se da mnogi modeli bola koji su bili predloženi, na osnovu detaljne analize asimboličkog bola, prestaju da budu uverljivo objašnjenje bola. Tu se, pre svega, misli na funkcionalističku analizu i tzv. perceptivni model bola, ali se isti zaključak nameće i za subjektivističke tvrdnje, prema kojima je oset bola suštinska komponenta našeg celovitog iskustva bola. AB - The main object of this paper is a rare syndrom in human pain experience, known as the pain asymbolia. The first thing that will be considered in this paper is the nature of pain asymbolia. I will try to examine and prove professor Grahek's claim that pain asymbolia differs from other dissociation syndromes in human pain experience. Also, the special attention will be given to Grahek's claim that typical cases of indifference to pain are not the cases of radical or total indifference to pain. Finally, it will be shown how pain asymbolia can be used against some famous arguments in the philosophy of mind. Namely, it can be used to undermine both the subjectivist and the objectivist conceptions of pain. More specifically, it can be used to disprove the functionalist interpretation of pain and the perceptual or representational model of pain. Also, pain asymbolia can be used against the subjectivist view, according to which the sensation of pain is to be considered as the essential component of pain. PB - Srpsko filozofsko društvo T2 - Theoria T1 - Asimbolički bol T1 - Pain Asymbolia EP - 84 IS - 2 SP - 63 VL - 55 DO - 10.2298/THEO1202063M ER -
@article{ author = "Milevski, Voin", year = "2012", abstract = "Glavni predmet ovog rada je redak disocijativni fenomen u ljudskom iskustvu bola, poznat kao asimbolija za bol (pain asymbolia). Prva stvar koja će se razmotriti u ovom radu je priroda asimboličkog bola, kao i specifičnosti po kojima se ovaj bol razlikuje od ostalih disocijativnih fenomena u ljudskom iskustvu bola. Naročita pažnja će biti posvećena tvrdnji profesora Graheka da klasični primeri ravnodušnosti prema bolu nisu slučajevi krajnje ili radikalne ravnodušnosti prema bolu, već da to mesto pripada upravo asimboličkom bolu. Na kraju, videćemo koje pretnje asimbolički bol postavlja pred neke istaknute argumente u filozofiji duha. Pokazaće se da mnogi modeli bola koji su bili predloženi, na osnovu detaljne analize asimboličkog bola, prestaju da budu uverljivo objašnjenje bola. Tu se, pre svega, misli na funkcionalističku analizu i tzv. perceptivni model bola, ali se isti zaključak nameće i za subjektivističke tvrdnje, prema kojima je oset bola suštinska komponenta našeg celovitog iskustva bola., The main object of this paper is a rare syndrom in human pain experience, known as the pain asymbolia. The first thing that will be considered in this paper is the nature of pain asymbolia. I will try to examine and prove professor Grahek's claim that pain asymbolia differs from other dissociation syndromes in human pain experience. Also, the special attention will be given to Grahek's claim that typical cases of indifference to pain are not the cases of radical or total indifference to pain. Finally, it will be shown how pain asymbolia can be used against some famous arguments in the philosophy of mind. Namely, it can be used to undermine both the subjectivist and the objectivist conceptions of pain. More specifically, it can be used to disprove the functionalist interpretation of pain and the perceptual or representational model of pain. Also, pain asymbolia can be used against the subjectivist view, according to which the sensation of pain is to be considered as the essential component of pain.", publisher = "Srpsko filozofsko društvo", journal = "Theoria", title = "Asimbolički bol, Pain Asymbolia", pages = "84-63", number = "2", volume = "55", doi = "10.2298/THEO1202063M" }
Milevski, V.. (2012). Asimbolički bol. in Theoria Srpsko filozofsko društvo., 55(2), 63-84. https://doi.org/10.2298/THEO1202063M
Milevski V. Asimbolički bol. in Theoria. 2012;55(2):63-84. doi:10.2298/THEO1202063M .
Milevski, Voin, "Asimbolički bol" in Theoria, 55, no. 2 (2012):63-84, https://doi.org/10.2298/THEO1202063M . .