Tipikon manastira Bogorodice Kosmosotire sevastokratora Isaka Komnina (1151/1152) - specifičnosti teksta i istorijski kontekst
The typikon of the Mother of God Kosmosoteira by sebastokratoros Isaakios (1151/1152): Historical context and the ktetor's intentions
Abstract
Tipikon manastira Bogorodice Kosmosotire kraj Vire u Trakiji predstavlja jedan od najinteresantinijih, ali i najsloženijih dokumenata ove vrste iz čitavog vizantijskog milenijuma. Ktitor manastira i pisac Tipikona, mlađi brat cara Jovana II Komnina, sevastokrator Isak, specifičan kako po svom izuzetnom obrazovanju, tako i po snažnim ambicijima da osvoji carsku vlast od brata, ostavio je vredno svedočanstvo o svojim stavovima, namerama, odnosu prema roditeljima i porodici i sopstvenom položaju u vreme zidanja zadužbine, sredinom 12. veka.
The ktetor of the Monastery of the Mother of God Kosmosoteira (World-Saviour), Sebastokrator Isaakios, third son and fifth child of the emperor Alexios I Komnenos, was one of the most interesting personalities within the ramified imperial family of the Komnenoi. As unsuccessful rebel against his brother the emperor John II, Isaakios was stigmatized for the rest of his life, and treated as a potential threat to the established hierarchy of the Komnenian family, together with his offspring, his sons John and Andronikos, the future emperor (1183-1185). As a consequence of his status of the 'eternal suspect' in the imperial family he was not allowed to carry through his plans about the burial in the Constantinopolitan monastery of Christ in Chora, which he had renovated, becoming its second ktetor. Instead, he was forced to provide another resting place for himself and the closest circle of his associates, far from the capital, and in a place without any political and ideological significa...nce, deep in Thracian province. There, or in Constantinople, Isaakios composed the Typikon for his monastery, which is preserved only in the late 16th century manuscript, from which both the edition princeps of L. Petit and G. Papazoglou's edition from 1994 spring. Late manuscript tradition presents many problems in reading or understanding the text, starting from the very 'title' of the document: although L. Petit's conjecture that the lacuna in the 'title' should be filled with the ktetor's title sebastokrator, having in mind the historical circumstances, the time of the Typikon's composition, and his insistence on the connection with his parents, it seems more plausible that the missing word was actually porphyrogennetos, frequently used in similar occasions. The founding document - the Typikon - of his monastery in Vira in Thrace, represents in many aspects a peculiar literary composition, both as a first-hand evidence of the literary prowess of its author, Isaakios himself, and as regards its political and ideological message, hidden mostly in the rare, but significant mentions of the ktetor's parents. Very much like his older sister Anna Komnene - who was writing her Alexiad exactly at the when Isaakios composed his Typikon (September 1, 1151- August 31, 1152) - Sebastokrator Isaakios tried to connect himself inseparably with their parents, Alexios I and Eirene Doukaina, in an attempt to underscore his political rectitude in spite the failed coup he had organized against his brother John II, and the formal acceptance of the latter's predominance which enabled their reconciliation. Not only were Alexios I and Eirene Doukaina the only relatives Isaakios mentioned, although relatives were usually met in abundance in similar documents, but the ktetor's description of his mother's last moments, and the signs of sanctity that occurred on her grave after her death provided for the exalted position of Eirene Doukaina who was transformed in Isaakios' personal mediator with the Mother of God, to Whom she had also dedicated a monastery in Constantinople. Eirene Doukaina's sainthood, to which Isaakios hinted, not ascertained in any other Byzantine text, could have served as a political leverage of the ktetor against the holiness of his sister-inlaw Eirene-Piroshka, John II's wife. Eirene-Piroshka's political sanctity, although apparently unusual for the 12th century Byzantium, played an important role in the final victory of John II over his opponents, his closest relatives, sister Anna and brother Isaakios, the ktetor of Kosmosoteira.
Keywords:
učenost / sevastokrator Isak / Komnini / ikos / Bogorodica / Balkan u 12. veku / Theotokos / The Balkan peninsula / Sebastokrator Isaac / oikos / education / ComnensSource:
Crkvene studije, 2011, 8, 8, 279-294Publisher:
- Centar za crkvene studije, Niš
Funding / projects:
Institution/Community
Istorija / HistoryTY - JOUR AU - Stanković, Vlada PY - 2011 UR - http://reff.f.bg.ac.rs/handle/123456789/1270 AB - Tipikon manastira Bogorodice Kosmosotire kraj Vire u Trakiji predstavlja jedan od najinteresantinijih, ali i najsloženijih dokumenata ove vrste iz čitavog vizantijskog milenijuma. Ktitor manastira i pisac Tipikona, mlađi brat cara Jovana II Komnina, sevastokrator Isak, specifičan kako po svom izuzetnom obrazovanju, tako i po snažnim ambicijima da osvoji carsku vlast od brata, ostavio je vredno svedočanstvo o svojim stavovima, namerama, odnosu prema roditeljima i porodici i sopstvenom položaju u vreme zidanja zadužbine, sredinom 12. veka. AB - The ktetor of the Monastery of the Mother of God Kosmosoteira (World-Saviour), Sebastokrator Isaakios, third son and fifth child of the emperor Alexios I Komnenos, was one of the most interesting personalities within the ramified imperial family of the Komnenoi. As unsuccessful rebel against his brother the emperor John II, Isaakios was stigmatized for the rest of his life, and treated as a potential threat to the established hierarchy of the Komnenian family, together with his offspring, his sons John and Andronikos, the future emperor (1183-1185). As a consequence of his status of the 'eternal suspect' in the imperial family he was not allowed to carry through his plans about the burial in the Constantinopolitan monastery of Christ in Chora, which he had renovated, becoming its second ktetor. Instead, he was forced to provide another resting place for himself and the closest circle of his associates, far from the capital, and in a place without any political and ideological significance, deep in Thracian province. There, or in Constantinople, Isaakios composed the Typikon for his monastery, which is preserved only in the late 16th century manuscript, from which both the edition princeps of L. Petit and G. Papazoglou's edition from 1994 spring. Late manuscript tradition presents many problems in reading or understanding the text, starting from the very 'title' of the document: although L. Petit's conjecture that the lacuna in the 'title' should be filled with the ktetor's title sebastokrator, having in mind the historical circumstances, the time of the Typikon's composition, and his insistence on the connection with his parents, it seems more plausible that the missing word was actually porphyrogennetos, frequently used in similar occasions. The founding document - the Typikon - of his monastery in Vira in Thrace, represents in many aspects a peculiar literary composition, both as a first-hand evidence of the literary prowess of its author, Isaakios himself, and as regards its political and ideological message, hidden mostly in the rare, but significant mentions of the ktetor's parents. Very much like his older sister Anna Komnene - who was writing her Alexiad exactly at the when Isaakios composed his Typikon (September 1, 1151- August 31, 1152) - Sebastokrator Isaakios tried to connect himself inseparably with their parents, Alexios I and Eirene Doukaina, in an attempt to underscore his political rectitude in spite the failed coup he had organized against his brother John II, and the formal acceptance of the latter's predominance which enabled their reconciliation. Not only were Alexios I and Eirene Doukaina the only relatives Isaakios mentioned, although relatives were usually met in abundance in similar documents, but the ktetor's description of his mother's last moments, and the signs of sanctity that occurred on her grave after her death provided for the exalted position of Eirene Doukaina who was transformed in Isaakios' personal mediator with the Mother of God, to Whom she had also dedicated a monastery in Constantinople. Eirene Doukaina's sainthood, to which Isaakios hinted, not ascertained in any other Byzantine text, could have served as a political leverage of the ktetor against the holiness of his sister-inlaw Eirene-Piroshka, John II's wife. Eirene-Piroshka's political sanctity, although apparently unusual for the 12th century Byzantium, played an important role in the final victory of John II over his opponents, his closest relatives, sister Anna and brother Isaakios, the ktetor of Kosmosoteira. PB - Centar za crkvene studije, Niš T2 - Crkvene studije T1 - Tipikon manastira Bogorodice Kosmosotire sevastokratora Isaka Komnina (1151/1152) - specifičnosti teksta i istorijski kontekst T1 - The typikon of the Mother of God Kosmosoteira by sebastokratoros Isaakios (1151/1152): Historical context and the ktetor's intentions EP - 294 IS - 8 SP - 279 VL - 8 UR - https://hdl.handle.net/21.15107/rcub_reff_1270 ER -
@article{ author = "Stanković, Vlada", year = "2011", abstract = "Tipikon manastira Bogorodice Kosmosotire kraj Vire u Trakiji predstavlja jedan od najinteresantinijih, ali i najsloženijih dokumenata ove vrste iz čitavog vizantijskog milenijuma. Ktitor manastira i pisac Tipikona, mlađi brat cara Jovana II Komnina, sevastokrator Isak, specifičan kako po svom izuzetnom obrazovanju, tako i po snažnim ambicijima da osvoji carsku vlast od brata, ostavio je vredno svedočanstvo o svojim stavovima, namerama, odnosu prema roditeljima i porodici i sopstvenom položaju u vreme zidanja zadužbine, sredinom 12. veka., The ktetor of the Monastery of the Mother of God Kosmosoteira (World-Saviour), Sebastokrator Isaakios, third son and fifth child of the emperor Alexios I Komnenos, was one of the most interesting personalities within the ramified imperial family of the Komnenoi. As unsuccessful rebel against his brother the emperor John II, Isaakios was stigmatized for the rest of his life, and treated as a potential threat to the established hierarchy of the Komnenian family, together with his offspring, his sons John and Andronikos, the future emperor (1183-1185). As a consequence of his status of the 'eternal suspect' in the imperial family he was not allowed to carry through his plans about the burial in the Constantinopolitan monastery of Christ in Chora, which he had renovated, becoming its second ktetor. Instead, he was forced to provide another resting place for himself and the closest circle of his associates, far from the capital, and in a place without any political and ideological significance, deep in Thracian province. There, or in Constantinople, Isaakios composed the Typikon for his monastery, which is preserved only in the late 16th century manuscript, from which both the edition princeps of L. Petit and G. Papazoglou's edition from 1994 spring. Late manuscript tradition presents many problems in reading or understanding the text, starting from the very 'title' of the document: although L. Petit's conjecture that the lacuna in the 'title' should be filled with the ktetor's title sebastokrator, having in mind the historical circumstances, the time of the Typikon's composition, and his insistence on the connection with his parents, it seems more plausible that the missing word was actually porphyrogennetos, frequently used in similar occasions. The founding document - the Typikon - of his monastery in Vira in Thrace, represents in many aspects a peculiar literary composition, both as a first-hand evidence of the literary prowess of its author, Isaakios himself, and as regards its political and ideological message, hidden mostly in the rare, but significant mentions of the ktetor's parents. Very much like his older sister Anna Komnene - who was writing her Alexiad exactly at the when Isaakios composed his Typikon (September 1, 1151- August 31, 1152) - Sebastokrator Isaakios tried to connect himself inseparably with their parents, Alexios I and Eirene Doukaina, in an attempt to underscore his political rectitude in spite the failed coup he had organized against his brother John II, and the formal acceptance of the latter's predominance which enabled their reconciliation. Not only were Alexios I and Eirene Doukaina the only relatives Isaakios mentioned, although relatives were usually met in abundance in similar documents, but the ktetor's description of his mother's last moments, and the signs of sanctity that occurred on her grave after her death provided for the exalted position of Eirene Doukaina who was transformed in Isaakios' personal mediator with the Mother of God, to Whom she had also dedicated a monastery in Constantinople. Eirene Doukaina's sainthood, to which Isaakios hinted, not ascertained in any other Byzantine text, could have served as a political leverage of the ktetor against the holiness of his sister-inlaw Eirene-Piroshka, John II's wife. Eirene-Piroshka's political sanctity, although apparently unusual for the 12th century Byzantium, played an important role in the final victory of John II over his opponents, his closest relatives, sister Anna and brother Isaakios, the ktetor of Kosmosoteira.", publisher = "Centar za crkvene studije, Niš", journal = "Crkvene studije", title = "Tipikon manastira Bogorodice Kosmosotire sevastokratora Isaka Komnina (1151/1152) - specifičnosti teksta i istorijski kontekst, The typikon of the Mother of God Kosmosoteira by sebastokratoros Isaakios (1151/1152): Historical context and the ktetor's intentions", pages = "294-279", number = "8", volume = "8", url = "https://hdl.handle.net/21.15107/rcub_reff_1270" }
Stanković, V.. (2011). Tipikon manastira Bogorodice Kosmosotire sevastokratora Isaka Komnina (1151/1152) - specifičnosti teksta i istorijski kontekst. in Crkvene studije Centar za crkvene studije, Niš., 8(8), 279-294. https://hdl.handle.net/21.15107/rcub_reff_1270
Stanković V. Tipikon manastira Bogorodice Kosmosotire sevastokratora Isaka Komnina (1151/1152) - specifičnosti teksta i istorijski kontekst. in Crkvene studije. 2011;8(8):279-294. https://hdl.handle.net/21.15107/rcub_reff_1270 .
Stanković, Vlada, "Tipikon manastira Bogorodice Kosmosotire sevastokratora Isaka Komnina (1151/1152) - specifičnosti teksta i istorijski kontekst" in Crkvene studije, 8, no. 8 (2011):279-294, https://hdl.handle.net/21.15107/rcub_reff_1270 .